HTML Document View

Full title: Notice of motion/application for Order Approving Four Compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb & Lack Regarding Allocation of Fees Pursuant to Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 9019; Opportunity to Request a Hearing with Proof of Service Filed by Trustee Elissa Miller (TR) (RE: related document(s)613 Motion to Approve Compromise Under Rule 9019 Four Compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb & Lack Regarding Allocation of Contingency Fees; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration of Elissa D. Miller in Support with Proof of Service Filed by Trustee Elissa Miller (TR)). (Andrassy, Kyra) (Entered: 08/23/2021)

Document posted on Aug 22, 2021 in the bankruptcy, 9 pages and 0 tables.

Bankrupt11 Summary (Automatically Generated)

el 17 PROCEDURE 9019; OPPORTUNITY TO T REQUEST A HEARING 18 [No Hearing Required Pursuant to Local 19 Bankruptcy Rule 9013-1(o)] 20 21 TO ALL INTERESTED PARTIES: 22 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Elissa D. Miller, the chapter 7 trustee for the bankruptcestate of Girardi Keese (the "Trustee"), has filed a Motion for Order Authorizing Four 23 Compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb & Lack Regarding Allocation of Contingency Fees inFour Cases Pursuant to Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 9019The Motion requests approval of four compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb Lack ("ELL") and others regarding the allocation of contingency fees earned in cases where 27 the Debtor acted as the plaintiffs' counsel pre-petition.Prior to the Petition Date, an action was commenced in the Los Angeles Count26 Superior Court on behalf of plaintiff Benjamin Medina entitled Medina v. Porsche USet al, Case No. 19STCV41582 (the "Medina Case"). true and correct copy of the foregoing document entitled (specify): NOTICE OF MOTION FOR ORDER APPROVING OUR COMPROMISES WITH ENGSTROM, LIPSCOMB & LACK REGARDING ALLOCATION OF CONTINGENCY EES PURSUANT TO FEDERAL RULE OF BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURE 9019; OPPORTUNITY TO REQUEST A EARING will be served or was served (a) on the judge in chambers in the form and manner required by LBR 5005-2(d);nd (b) in the manner stated below: .P. 5 and/or controlling LBR, on (date) , I served the following ersons and/or entities by personal delivery, overnight mail service, or (for those who consented in writing to such servicethod), by facsimile transmission and/or email as follows.

List of Tables

Document Contents

1 SMILEY WANG-EKVALL, LLP Kyra E. Andrassy, State Bar No. 207959 2 kandrassy@swelawfirm.com Philip E. Strok, State Bar No. 169296 3 pstrok@swelawfirm.com Timothy W. Evanston, State Bar No. 319342 4 tevanston@swelawfirm.com 3200 Park Center Drive, Suite 250 5 Costa Mesa, California 92626 Telephone: 714 445-1000 6 Facsimile: 714 445-1002 7 Attorneys for Elissa D. Miller, Chapter 7 Trustee 8 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 10 LOS ANGELES DIVISION 11 2 0 0 92626 4 445-1 1123 I GnI RreA RDI KEESE, CCahsaep tNero 7. 2:20-bk-21022-BR ornia ax 71 a, Calif00 • F 14 NAPOPTRICOEV OINFG M FOOTUIORN C FOOMRP ORORDMEISRE S s0 15 WITH ENGSTROM, LIPSCOMB & LACK e1 M5- REGARDING ALLOCATION OF a 4 ost4 4 16 Debtor. CONTINGENCY FEES PURSUANT TO C71 FEDERAL RULE OF BANKRUPTCY el 17 PROCEDURE 9019; OPPORTUNITY TO T REQUEST A HEARING 18 [No Hearing Required Pursuant to Local 19 Bankruptcy Rule 9013-1(o)] 20 21 TO ALL INTERESTED PARTIES: 22 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Elissa D. Miller, the chapter 7 trustee for the bankruptcestate of Girardi Keese (the "Trustee"), has filed a Motion for Order Authorizing Four 23 Compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb & Lack Regarding Allocation of Contingency Fees inFour Cases Pursuant to Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 9019 (the "Motion"). The 24 Trustee is requesting that the Motion be granted without a hearing as provided in Local Bankruptcy Rule 9013-1(o) unless a party in interest timely files and serves a written 25 opposition to the Motion and requests a hearing. The Motion is summarized as follows: 26 1. The Motion requests approval of four compromises with Engstrom, Lipscomb Lack ("ELL") and others regarding the allocation of contingency fees earned in cases where 27 the Debtor acted as the plaintiffs' counsel pre-petition. David Lira ("Lira") of ELL, who was employed by the Debtor until approximately July 2020, subsequently substituted in as 28 counsel and has been the attorney primarily responsible for prosecuting the cases. Three of

1

1 the four cases have recently settled and one is still pending. The compromises contemplatein the Motion were reached after taking into account the efforts by all parties in prosecuting 2 the cases. The Trustee believes the compromises are fair and equitable and in the best interest of the Estate. 3 (a) Settlement with ELL and Koushan re Atkinson v. Garcia. Prior to the 4 Petition Date, an action was commenced in the Los Angeles County Superior Court on behalf of plaintiffs Richard Atkinson, Arlene Garcia Lopez, and Maria Rocio Garcia5 (collectively, "Plaintiff") entitled Richard Atkinson, et al, v. Cheryl Lynn Graham Elliston, Case No. BC640609. The Atkinson Case was referred to the Debtor by The 6 Law Offices of F. Anthony Koushan, PC ("Koushan"). Koushan filed the Atkinson Case in approximately 2015 and, in 2018, when it appeared the Atkinson Case would7 be heading to trial, associated the Debtor. The Trustee, ELL, and Koushan have reached an agreement with respect to the allocation of the contingency fee. Pursuan8 to the agreement, the Estate's share of the Contingency Fee is 20%, or $14,400.00 and ELL and Koushan will share 80% of the Contingency Fee, or $57,600.00. A cop9 of the Atkinson Agreement, which fully sets out the terms of the settlement, is attached Exhibit "1" to the Motion. 10 (b) Settlement with ELL re Roach v. Hunter. Prior to the Petition Date, the 11 Debtor commenced an action in the Los Angeles County Superior Court on behalf of 2 plaintiff Tamara Roach (the "Plaintiff") entitled Roach v. Hunter, Case No. 0 0 92626 4 445-1 1123 2trhe0eimS gTbrCuorsVss0e 8am2me6on0ut. noTtf h oceof safetnsey. a rIegncr eaoepvmperreoyn xoti mbptraaotienviledyd eJ sau flftyoe r2r t0thh2ee0 D,f iLleinibrgato osr fut otbh sretei tccuoetemivdep ilana inpfote,r r pctheluens tD aegbet ooornia ax 71 and undertook the prosecution of the Roach Case. Lira recently settled the Roach a, Calif00 • F 14 Calaloscea. t ioTnh eo fT trhues tceoen atinndg eEnLcLy hfeaev ew rheicahc hperodv aidne asg trheaetm theen tE wstiathte r'ess spheacrte t oo ft hthee s0 15 Contingency Fee is 25%, or $10,000.00 and ELL's share of the Contingency Fee is e1 M5- 75%, or $30,000.00. The Estate will receive $16,904.85 for costs incurred by the a 4 ost4 4 16 Debtor in connection with the case. A copy of the Roach Agreement, which fully setsC71 out the terms of the settlement, is attached to the Motion as Exhibit "2." el 17 T (c) Settlement with ELL re Saspe v. Chuc. Prior to the Petition Date, the 18 Debtor commenced an action in the Los Angeles County Superior Court on behalf of plaintiff Daniela Saspe entitled Saspe v. Chuc, Case No. 19STCV41842. Lira was th19 attorney primarily responsible for the Saspe Case while he was employed by the Debtor. The Debtor was to receive a percentage of the gross amount of any recover20 obtained after the filing of the complaint, plus reimbursement of costs. In approximately July 2020, Lira substituted in as Saspe's new counsel and 21 subsequently settled the Saspe Case. The Trustee and ELL have reached an agreement with respect to the allocation of the contingency fee. Pursuant to the 22 agreement, the Estate's share of the Contingency Fee is 20%, or $2,500.00, and ELL's share of the Contingency Fee is 80%, or $10,000.00. The Estate will receive 23 $3,050.48 for costs incurred by the Debtor in connection with the Saspe Case. A copof the Saspe Agreement which fully sets forth the terms of the agreement is attached 24 to the Motion as Exhibit "3." 25 (d) Settlement with ELL and The Capital Law Firm re Medina v. Porsche USA. Prior to the Petition Date, an action was commenced in the Los Angeles Count26 Superior Court on behalf of plaintiff Benjamin Medina entitled Medina v. Porsche USet al, Case No. 19STCV41582 (the "Medina Case"). Capital was initially retained by 27 the Plaintiff, and Capital subsequently associated the Debtor as co-counsel. The fee agreement provides that the Debtor would receive a percentage of the gross amount 28 of any recovery obtained after the filing of the complaint, plus reimbursement of costs

2

1 In approximately July 2020, Lira substituted in for the Debtor and undertook the prosecution of Plaintiff's case. Although the Medina Case is still pending, the Trustee 2 ELL, and Capital have reached an agreement with respect to the allocation of the contingency fee (the "Medina Agreement"). Pursuant to the agreement, Capital's 3 share of the Contingency Fee is 40%. The remaining 60% will be shared by ELL andthe Estate, with ELL receiving 80% and the Estate receiving 20%. The Estate will 4 receive $8,822.57 for costs incurred by the Debtor in connection with the case. A copy of the Medina Agreement, which fully sets out the terms of the settlement, is 5 attached to the Motion as Exhibit "4." 6 2. The settlements are reasonable and in the best interest of the Debtor's Estate. The allocation of the contingency fees considers the role and effort put forward by ELL and 7 the other associated counsel in relation to the work performed by the Debtor. The Trustee negotiated these settlements to minimize the risks and costs associated with possible 8 litigation if the parties were unable to arrive at an equitable resolution. In the absence of a consensual resolution, the Estate would have to litigate a quantum meruit claim for fees and 9 costs. The litigation would be time consuming and would require a significant expenditure ofthe Estate's resources. The Trustee believes that the upside is marginal even if the Trustee 10 were to be successful in the litigation. Moreover, no litigation is without risk. The Trustee evaluated the potential strengths and weaknesses of the Estate's position in the litigation an11 negotiated the settlements described in this Motion in an effort to maximize the return to 2 creditors. The compromises were entered into in good faith and were negotiated at arm's 0 0 92626 4 445-1 1123 length. D EADLINE FOR FILING AND SERVING OPPOSITION PAPERS AND REQUEST ornia ax 71 FOR A HEARING: Pursuant to LBR 9013-1(o), any party who opposes the Motion may a, Calif00 • F 14 rreeqquueesstt afo hr ehaerainrign go nis t1h4e dMaoytsio na.f t eTrh teh ed edaadteli noef stoe rfviliec ea nodf tsheisrv neo ati cwer,i tpteluns o3p apdodsiittiioonn aal ndda ys ifs0 15 you were served by mail or pursuant to F.R.Civ.P. 5(b)(2)(D) or (F). e1 M5- a 4 ost4 4 16 If you timely file and serve a written opposition and request for a hearing, the Trustee C71 will file and serve a notice of hearing at least 14 days in advance of the hearing. If you fail toel 17 comply with this deadline: T 18 (a) The Trustee will file a declaration to indicate (1) the Motion was properlserved, (2) the response period elapsed, and (3) no party filed and served a written 19 opposition and request for a hearing within 14 days after the date of service of the notice; 20 (b) The Trustee will lodge an order that the Court may use to grant the 21 Motion; and 22 The Court may treat your failure as a waiver of your right to oppose the Motion and may grant the Motion without further hearing and notice. 23 DATED: August 23, 2021 SMILEY WANG-EKVALL, LLP 24 25 By: /s/ Kyra E. Andrassy KYRA E. ANDRASSY 26 Attorneys for Elissa D. Miller, Chapter 7 Truste 27 28

3

PROOF OF SERVICE OF DOCUMENT am over the age of 18 and not a party to this bankruptcy case or adversary proceeding. My business address is 3200 ark Center Drive, Suite 250, Costa Mesa, CA 92626. true and correct copy of the foregoing document entitled (specify): NOTICE OF MOTION FOR ORDER APPROVING OUR COMPROMISES WITH ENGSTROM, LIPSCOMB & LACK REGARDING ALLOCATION OF CONTINGENCY EES PURSUANT TO FEDERAL RULE OF BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURE 9019; OPPORTUNITY TO REQUEST A EARING will be served or was served (a) on the judge in chambers in the form and manner required by LBR 5005-2(d);nd (b) in the manner stated below: . TO BE SERVED BY THE COURT VIA NOTICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING (NEF): Pursuant to controlling General rders and LBR, the foregoing document will be served by the court via NEF and hyperlink to the document. On (date) ugust 23, 2021 I checked the CM/ECF docket for this bankruptcy case or adversary proceeding and determined that e following persons are on the Electronic Mail Notice List to receive NEF transmission at the email addresses stated elow:  Service information continued on attached pag . SERVED BY UNITED STATES MAIL: n (date)) August 23, 2021, I served the following persons and/or entities at the last known addresses in this bankruptcy ase or adversary proceeding by placing a true and correct copy thereof in a sealed envelope in the United States mail, rst class, postage prepaid, and addressed as follows. Listing the judge here constitutes a declaration that mailing to the dge will be completed no later than 24 hours after the document is filed. he Honorable Barry Russell .S. Bankruptcy Court oybal Federal Building 55 E. Temple Street, Suite 1660 os Angeles, CA 900125  Service information continued on attached pag . SERVED BY PERSONAL DELIVERY, OVERNIGHT MAIL, FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION OR EMAIL (state method r each person or entity served): Pursuant to F.R.Civ.P. 5 and/or controlling LBR, on (date) , I served the following ersons and/or entities by personal delivery, overnight mail service, or (for those who consented in writing to such servicethod), by facsimile transmission and/or email as follows. Listing the judge here constitutes a declaration that personal elivery on, or overnight mail to, the judge will be completed no later than 24 hours after the document is filed.  Service information continued on attached pag declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true and correct. August 23, 2021 Gabriela Gomez-Cruz /s/ Gabriela Gomez-Cruz Date Printed Name Signature

4

O BE SERVED BY THE COURT VIA NOTICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING (NEF):  Kyra E Andrassy kandrassy@swelawfirm.com, lgarrett@swelawfirm.com;gcruz@swelawfirm.com;jchung@swelawfirm.com  Rafey Balabanian rbalabanian@edelson.com, docket@edelson.com  Michelle Balady mb@bedfordlg.com, leo@bedfordlg.com  Ori S Blumenfeld ori@marguliesfaithlaw.com, Helen@MarguliesFaithLaw.com;Angela@MarguliesFaithLaw.com;Vicky@MarguliesFaithLaw.com  Evan C Borges eborges@ggtriallaw.com, cwinsten@ggtriallaw.com  Richard D Buckley richard.buckley@arentfox.com  Marie E Christiansen mchristiansen@vedderprice.com, ecfladocket@vedderprice.com,marie-christiansen-4166@ecf.pacerpro.com  Jennifer Witherell Crastz jcrastz@hrhlaw.com  Ashleigh A Danker Ashleigh.danker@dinsmore.com, SDCMLFiles@DINSMORE.COM;Katrice.ortiz@dinsmore.com  Clifford S Davidson csdavidson@swlaw.com, jlanglois@swlaw.com;cliff-davidson-7586@ecf.pacerpro.com  Lei Lei Wang Ekvall lekvall@swelawfirm.com, lgarrett@swelawfirm.com;gcruz@swelawfirm.com;jchung@swelawfirm.com  Richard W Esterkin richard.esterkin@morganlewis.com  Timothy W Evanston tevanston@swelawfirm.com, gcruz@swelawfirm.com;lgarrett@swelawfirm.com;jchung@swelawfirm.com  Jeremy Faith Jeremy@MarguliesFaithlaw.com, Helen@MarguliesFaithlaw.com;Angela@MarguliesFaithlaw.com;Vicky@MarguliesFaithlaw.com  James J Finsten , jimfinsten@hotmail.com  Alan W Forsley alan.forsley@flpllp.com, awf@fkllawfirm.com,awf@fl-lawyers.net,addy.flores@flpllp.com  Eric D Goldberg eric.goldberg@dlapiper.com, eric-goldberg-1103@ecf.pacerpro.com  Andrew Goodman agoodman@andyglaw.com, Goodman.AndrewR102467@notify.bestcase.com  Suzanne C Grandt suzanne.grandt@calbar.ca.gov, joan.randolph@calbar.ca.gov  Steven T Gubner sgubner@bg.law, ecf@bg.law  Marshall J Hogan mhogan@swlaw.com, knestuk@swlaw.com  Sheryl K Ith sith@cookseylaw.com, sith@ecf.courtdrive.com  Razmig Izakelian razmigizakelian@quinnemanuel.com  Lillian Jordan ENOTICES@DONLINRECANO.COM, RMAPA@DONLINRECANO.COM  Lewis R Landau Lew@Landaunet.com  Daniel A Lev dlev@sulmeyerlaw.com, ccaldwell@sulmeyerlaw.com;dlev@ecf.inforuptcy.com  Elizabeth A Lombard elombard@zwickerpc.com, bknotices@zwickerpc.com  Craig G Margulies Craig@MarguliesFaithlaw.com, Vicky@MarguliesFaithlaw.com;Helen@MarguliesFaithlaw.com;Angela@MarguliesFaithlaw.com  Ron Maroko ron.maroko@usdoj.gov  Peter J Mastan peter.mastan@dinsmore.com, SDCMLFiles@dinsmore.com;Katrice.ortiz@dinsmore.com  Edith R. Matthai ematthai@romalaw.com, lrobie@romalaw.com  Kenneth Miller kmiller@pmcos.com, efilings@pmcos.com  Elissa Miller (TR) CA71@ecfcbis.com, MillerTrustee@Sulmeyerlaw.com;C124@ecfcbis.com;ccaldwell@sulmeyerlaw.com  Eric A Mitnick MitnickLaw@aol.com, mitnicklaw@gmail.com  Scott H Olson solson@vedderprice.com, scott-olson-2161@ecf.pacerpro.com,ecfsfdocket@vedderprice.com,nortega@vedderprice.com  Carmela Pagay ctp@lnbyb.com  Leonard Pena lpena@penalaw.com, penasomaecf@gmail.com;penalr72746@notify.bestcase.com  Michael J Quinn mquinn@vedderprice.com, ecfladocket@vedderprice.com,michael-quinn-2870@ecf.pacerpro.com  David M Reeder david@reederlaw.com, secretary@reederlaw.com  Ronald N Richards ron@ronaldrichards.com, morani@ronaldrichards.com  Kevin C Ronk Kevin@portilloronk.com, Attorneys@portilloronk.com  Frank X Ruggier frank@ruggierlaw.com, enotice@pricelawgroup.com  William F Savino wsavino@woodsoviatt.com, lherald@woodsoviatt.com  Kenneth John Shaffer johnshaffer@quinnemanuel.com  Richard M Steingard , awong@steingardlaw.com  Philip E Strok pstrok@swelawfirm.com, gcruz@swelawfirm.com;1garrett@swelawfirm.com;jchung@swelawfirm.com  Boris Treyzon bt@treyzon.com, sgonzales@actslaw.com  United States Trustee (LA) ustpregion16.la.ecf@usdoj.gov  Eric D Winston ericwinston@quinnemanuel.com  Christopher K.S. Wong christopher.wong@arentfox.com, yvonne.li@arentfox.com  Timothy J Yoo tjy@lnbyb.com

5

SERVED BY UNITED STATES MAIL: 9039 GLADIOLUS DR.  ABIR COHEN TREYZON SALO, LLP, A  AMERICAN EXPRESS NATIONAL BANK C/O ANYON COUNTRY, CA 91387‐1829  CALIFORNIA LAW FIRM  ZWICKER & 16001 VENTURA BOULEVARD,   80 MINUTEMAN ROAD  SUITE 200  P.O. BOX 9043  ENCINO, CA 91436‐4482  ANDOVER, MA 01810‐0943  MERICAN EXPRESS TRAVEL RELATED  AMY FISCH SOLOMON  ANDREW GOODMAN ERVICES COM  P.O. BOX 1958  30700 RUSSELL RANCH ROAD  /O ZWICKER AND ASSOCIATES, P.C.  SANTA YNEZ, CA 93460‐1958  SUITE 250 .O. 9043  WESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA 91362‐9507  NDOVER, MA 01810‐0943  TKINSON‐BAKER, INC.  BAKER, KEENER & NAHRA, LLP  BEDFORD LAW GROUP, APC 00 N. BRAND BLVD. 3RD FLOOR  633 WEST FIFTH STREET  1875 CENTURY PARK EAST LENDALE CA 91203‐1945  SUITE 5500  SUITE 1790  LOS ANGELES, CA 90071‐2014  CENTURY CITY, CA 90067‐2537  EDFORD LAW GROUP, APC  CT3MEDIA, INC. CHET THOMPSON  BRANDON STOKES 875 CENTURY PARK EAST, SUITE 1790  26080 SHADOW ROCK LN   4638 WOODLANDS VILLAGE DRIVE S ANGELES, CA 90067‐2537  VALENCIA, CA 91381‐0630  ORLANDO, FL 32835‐2719 RIAN ARMSTEAD  BRIAN GARRETT  COHEN & COHEN, LLP  5 WATKINS AVENUE  15 S. ROLLING HILLS AVE  16130 VENTURA BLVD.  OODBURY, NJ 08096‐1235  IRWIN, PA 15642‐3220  SUITE 140  ENCINO, CA 91436‐2582  ALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH CARE    CHRISTIAN PETTY  ERVICE  6607 5TH AVENUE  ICHAEL BYERTS  RIO LINDA, CA 95673‐3409  00 S. SPRING STREET, SUITE 1702  S ANGELES CA 90013‐1256  HRISTINA FULTON  CODY THOMPSON  CIGNA HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE 875 CENTURY PARK EAST  12040 DRIFTSTONE DRIVE  COMPANY  UITE 2230  FISHERS, IN 46037‐8405  MARYLOU RICE  S ANGELES, CA 90067‐2522  LEGAL COMPLIANCE LEAD ANALYST  900 COTTAGE GROVE ROAD, B6LPA  HARTFORD CT 06152‐0001  EPARTMENT OF HEALTH CARE SERVICES  DJK COUNSEL, LTD.  DK GLOBAL, INC.  FFICE OF LEGAL SERVICES MS 0010  C/O DANIEL J. KATZ  420 MISSOURI CT TTN STEVEN A OLDHAM STAFF ATTORNEY  1925 CENTURY PARK E, #810  REDLANDS, CA 92373‐3128 O BOX 997413  LOS ANGELES, CA 90067‐2709  ACRAMENTO CA 95899‐7413  AIMLER TRUST  DAIMLER TRUST  DALTON & ASSOCIATES  /O BK SERVICING, LLC  C/O BK SERVICING, LLC  1106 WEST TENTH STREET O BOX 131265  PO BOX 131265  WILMINGTON, DE 19806‐4522  OSEVILLE, MN 55113‐0011  ROSEVILLE, MN 55113‐0011   

6

AVID R. LIRA  DEVIN LYNN SCOTT  DOMINIC LOMBARDO  0100 SANTA MONICA BOULEVARD, 12TH  512 BRAGINTON ST LOT 2  115 E. POMONA BOULEVARD LOOR  CLEARWATER, FL 33756‐1565  SUITE A  S ANGELES, CA 90067‐4003  MONTEREY PARK, CA 91755‐7210  ONLIN, RECANO & COMPANY  EDELSON PC  DAYMOND WALTON  201  15TH AVE  150 CALIFORNIA STREET, 18TH FLOOR  11 WALTON HERNDON DRIVE ROOKLYN, NY 11219‐5411  SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111‐4569  MEHERRIN, VA 23954‐2836 RED W. BAPTISTA  ERIC BRYAN SEUTHE  ERIC GOLDBERG  0 LAKEVIEW DRIVE  10990 WILSHIRE BLVD.  DLA PIPER LLP (US)  ARRAGANSETT, RI 02882‐1617  SUITE 1420  2000 AVENUE OF THE STARS, #400 LOS ANGELES, CA 90024‐3931  LOS ANGELES 90067‐4735  RIC LINDVALL, DO  ERIKA GIRARDI  ERIKA SALDANA  04 N MAGNOLIA AVE SUITE 100  C/O DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP  1757 RIVERSIDE DRIVE LOVIS, CA 93611‐9205  550 SOUTH HOPE STREET, SUITE 1765  GLENDALE, CA 91201‐2856 LOS ANGELES, CA 90071‐2669  FFREY M. SCHWARTZ  ESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS, LLC.  EXPRESS NETWORK LLC UCH SHELIST  2700 CENTENNIAL TOWER 101 MARIETTA ST  1605 W OLYMPIC BLVD #800 91 N. WACKER DRIVE, SUITE 1800  ATLANTA, GA 30303  LOS ANGELES CA 90015‐4685 HICAGO, IL 60606‐1631  AY PUGH  FRANTZ LAW GROUP, APLC  GAYLE C. KUROSU  163 DANIELS DRIVE  2029 CENTURY PARK EAST  1116 WEST 187TH STREET S ANGELES, CA 90035‐1101  #400  GARDENA, CA 90248‐4123  LOS ANGELES, CA 90067‐2905  IRARDI KEESE  GOLKOW LITIGATION SERVICES, LLC  HAKEEM DAUL SHACQUIL DANLEY ( HOBSON)126 WILSHIRE BLVD  GOLKOW LITIGATION SERVICES  901 TUCKER STREET S ANGELES, CA 90017‐1904  1650 MARKET STREET, SUITE 5150  WILLIAMSPORT, PA 17701‐3627 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103‐7249  ENRY ANDREW PEREZ BETANCUR  IDISCOVERY SOLUTIONS  ISRAEL I CASSARO 887 VIA PALM LAKES  535 ANTON BLVD STE 850  2723 CAMBRIDGE AVE 506  COSTA MESA, CA 92626‐7062  HEMET, CA 92545‐5315  EST PALM BEACH, FL 33417‐2728  MS, INC.  JOSEFINA CASTILLO‐HERNANDEZ  JAIME RUIGOMEZ  8881 VON KARMAN AVE., SUITE 350  27604 FIREBRAND DR  C/O MARGULIES FAITH, LLP VINE, CA 92612‐6589  CASTAIC, CA 91384‐3583  16030 VENTURA BLVD., STE. 470 ENCINO, CA 91436‐4493  HOSHAPHAT SHAMBEE  JILL O'CALLAHAN  JOSHUA REMNANT  NDA SHAMBEE   1437 CLUB VIEW DRIVE  535 WATERVLIET AVE  N BEHALF OF JEHOSPHAT SHAMBEE  LOS ANGELES, CA 90024‐5305  DAYTON, OH 45420‐2542 21 KAREY DRIVE  EMPLE TX 76502‐8730  HN ABASSIAN  JUDY SELBERG  JOHN EDWARD TILLSON IV  403 VAN NUYS BOULEVARD  10990 WILSHIRE BLVD., SUITE 1420  W179S6562 HARDTKE DRIVE AN NUYS, CA 91401‐1437  LOS ANGELES, CA 90024‐3931  MUSKEGO, WI 53150‐9694 

7

HNSON CONTROLS SECURITY SOLUTIONS  JORDAN DEWANZ‐ TITUS  JOSEPH RUIGOMEZ 0405 CROSSPOINT BLVD  488 SNELLING AVE S  C/O MARGULIES FAITH, LLP DIANAPOLIS, IN 46256‐3323  #112  16030 VENTURA BLVD., STE. 470 SAINT PAUL, MN 55116‐1555  ENCINO, CA 91436‐4493  ABC‐AM RADIO, INC.  KCC CLASS ACTION SERVICES, LLC  KIMBERLY ARCHIE /O CRF SOLUTIONS  C/O DRAKE FOSTER  15210 VENTURA BOULEVARD O BOX 1389  222 N PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY, 3RD FLOOR  SUITE 307 IMI VALLEY, CA 93062‐1389  EL SEGUNDO, CA 90245‐5648  SHERMAN OAKS, CA 91403‐3841 ATHLEEN L. BAJGROWICZ  KATHLEEN RUIGOMEZ  KIMBERLY ANNE COLEMAN ANUEL H. MILLER, ESQ.  C/O MARGULIES FAITH, LLP  416 VISTA ROMA W OFFICES OF MANUEL H. MILLER  16030 VENTURA BLVD. STE. 470  NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660‐3513 0750 VENTURA BOULEVARD, SUITE 440  ENCINO, CA 91436‐4493  OODLAND HILLS, CA 91364‐6643   EVERETT & ASSOCIATES, LLC  L.A. ARENA FUNDING, LLC  MANUEL H. MILLER 700 STATE STREET, SUITE 350  C/O RICHARD D. BUCKLEY, JR.  20750 VENTURA BOULEVARD ANTA BARBARA, CA 93105‐3100  ARENT FOX LLP  SUITE 440  555 WEST FIFTH STREET, 48TH FLOOR  WOODLAND HILLS, CA 91364‐6643 LOS ANGELES, CA 90013‐1065  W OFFICES OF PHILI SHELDON APC  LAW OFFICES OF PHILIP R. SHELDON, APC  LAW OFFICES OF ROBERT P. FINN /O SPERTUS LANDES UMHOFER  C/O SPERTUS, LANDES, & UMHOFER, LLP  C/O SPERTUS, LANDES & UMHOFER, LLP 990 S. BUNDY DR. SUITE  1990 S. BUNDY DR., SUITE 705  1990 S. BUNDY SUITE 705 S ANGELES, CA 90025‐5240  LOS ANGELES, CA 90025‐5256  LOS ANGELES, CA 90025‐5256 ARLATT CONSULTING  MATTHEW JONES  MICAH S BEAL  5 CRESTA VERDE DR  317 E 4TH STREET  419 GREENWOOD AVE  OLLING HILLS ESTATES, CA 90274‐5455  LYNDON, KS 66451‐9550  MICHIGAN CITY, IN 46360‐5423 ICHAEL VISLOSKY  MICHAEL HAMBRIGHT  SAMMY Y. HSU  764 CERES AVE  3980 SAN BENITO AVE.  13044 PACIFIC PROMENADE HICO CA 95973‐7814  SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92407‐6042  APT 423  PLAYA VISTA, CA 90094‐4006  ANO BANC  NICKALAS MAURICE WILSON  NOEL MONTES  /O EDWARD PADILLA  C/O MARY DANIEL WILSON  2117 BENJAMIN CREEK DR 755 IRVINE CENTER DRIVE, 3RD FLOOR  1011 BROADWAY ROAD  LITTLE ELM, TX 75068‐0019 VINE, CA 92618‐2904  SANFORD, SC 27332‐9792  WEN, PATTERSON & OWEN  PAULINE WHITE  PETER ANAKARAONYE  /O LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL N. BERKE  150 N. SANTA ANITA AVENUE  3218 DUNLAP LANE APT E 5001 THE OLD ROAD  SUITE 300  MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055‐7056  ANTA CLARITA, CA 91381‐2252  ARCADIA, CA 91006‐3116  ETERSON & ASSOCIATES COURT REPORTING,  PITNEY BOWES GLOBAL FINANCIAL SERVICES  PITNEY BOWES INC C.  LLC  27 WATERVIEW DR, 3RD FL  30 B STREET, SUITE 350  27 WATERVIEW DRIVE  SHELTON, CT 06484‐4361 AN DIEGO, CA 92101‐4403  SHELTON, CT 06484‐4301  ROFESSIONAL RECRUITERS INC.  REST YOUR CASE EVIDENCE STORAGE LLC  ROBERT GIRARDI 3428 MAXELLA AVE #404  PAULINE WHITE  402 SOUTH MARENGO AVE.  S ANGELES, CA 90292‐5620  150 N. SANTA ANITA AVENUE  SUITE B SUITE 300  PASADENA, CA 91101‐3113  ARCADIA, CA 91006‐3116 

8

OBERT KEESE  ROBERT M. KEESE  SHANE JETER  2982 ROSEMONT COURT  22982 ROSEMONT COURT  2550 WALLINGFORD ROAD URRIETA, CA 92562‐3075  MURRIETA, CA 92562‐3075  WINSTON SALEM, NC 27101‐1922 ONALD RICHARDS  RONNELL TAYLOR ON THE BEHALF OF SADIE  SHANE MORGAN W OFFICE OF RONALD RICHARDS & ASSOC  TAYLOR  28 JACKSON AVE .O. BOX 11480  114 RACQUET CLUB DR #608  RUTLAND, VT 05701‐4523 EVERLY HILLS, CA 90213‐4480  GREENSBURG, PA 15601‐9033  IMBA CAPITAL INC.  ROBERT COHAN  STILLWELL MADISON  SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY  AVE AT PORT IMPERIAL 408  C/O DLA PIPER LLP (US)  555 WEST 5TH STREET EST NEW YORK, NJ 07093‐7141  2000 AVENUE OF THE STARS, #400  LOS ANGELES, CA 90013‐1011 LOS ANGELES, CA 90067‐4735  HOMAS A. SCHRANDT  U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT, INC.  THE LAW BUSINESS INSIDER RADIO SHOW /O MARVIN E. HARVEY JR. (POA)  C/O PORTILLO RONK LEGAL TEAM  13428 MAXELLA AVE #404 07 FAIRWAY DR.  5716 CORSA AVENUE  LOS ANGELES, CA 90292‐5620 EW SMYRNA BCH, FL 32168‐6114  SUITE 207  WESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA 91362‐4059  S LEGAL SUPPORT  VIRGINIA ANTONIO  VIRAGE SPV 1, LLC  6825 NORTHCHASE DRSUITE 900  20413 VIA NAVARRA  CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY OUSTON, TX 77060‐6004  YORBA LINDA, CA 92886‐3065  251 LITTLE FALLS DRIVE WILMINGTON, DE 19808‐1674  ITITOE LAW GROUP  WELLS FARGO VENDOR FINANCIAL SERVICES,  C/O CRF SOLUTIONS TTN: JAMES VITITOE  INC.  PO BOX 1389  707 CORSA AVENUE, 2ND FLOOR  C/O HEMAR, ROUSSO & HEALD, LLP  SIMI VALLEY, CA 93062‐1389 ESTLAKE VILLAGE, CA 91362‐6499  15910 VENTURA BLVD., 12TH FLOOR ENCINO, CA 91436‐2802  ERALD J JACQUART AND LISA M JACQUART  RACHAEL DAVIS    355 E DODGE ST  45871 PINE HOLLOW RD  REMONT, NE 68025‐5765  ROGERS, OH 44455‐9736 

9